2022-Opinion: Why Tiafoe is probably not a symbol of things to come in tennis


Editor’s Observe: Harry Edwards, a sociologist and professor emeritus on the College of California, Berkeley, is the creator of “The Revolt of the Black Athlete,” about Black activism on the enjoying area and within the athletic area. The opinions expressed listed below are his personal. Learn extra opinion at CNN.


Should you watched Frances Tiafoe play on the US Open final week in hopes of seeing the following chapter within the evolution of a gifted tennis expertise, you then have been richly rewarded. However if you happen to have been searching for proof of efforts by officers within the sport to make sure that there are extra Tiafoes who observe in his footsteps, you will have to maintain ready.

Sunday’s US Open last noticed Spain’s Carlos Alcaraz defeat Norwegian Casper Ruud in 4 units. However as a scholar whose work has centered on Blacks in sport, I took a higher curiosity in Friday’s match between Alcaraz and Tiafoe, the first African American man to achieve the semi-finals of the US Open match since my pal, the late tennis nice Arthur Ashe, did it in 1972. Tiafoe misplaced to Alcaraz in a hard-fought battle, however his robust general efficiency on the Open put the sports activities world on discover that he would be the subsequent nice American participant to observe.

Harry Edwards

Now that Grand Slams are over and we will assess the yr in tennis, it’s outstanding to contemplate that the 2022 US Open was bracketed by the achievements of two extremely profitable Black gamers, in what stays an overwhelmingly White sport.

In Serena Williams, the US Open offered a becoming tribune for a tennis legend winding down a historic profession; In Tiafoe, it had a gifted younger up-and-comer with all of the promise on this planet. Each gamers needed to overcome financial hardship to search out success in a sport with a historical past of racial exclusion, one not historically kind to Black players.

The story of Serena – skilled as a toddler by her father, alongside together with her sister Venus on the public courts in Compton, California – is well-known.

Tiafoe had an much more hard-scrabble introduction to tennis, which he discovered to play on the identical courts that his father – an immigrant from battle torn Sierra Leone – helped construct as a member of the development crew. Later, his dad grew to become a upkeep employee on the facility, affording Tiafoe entry to the services, tools and coaching he would want to blossom within the sport.

LeBron James tweeted phrases of encouragement to Tiafoe after his gorgeous fourth-round upset over tennis star Rafael Nadal. Former first girl Michelle Obama turned out to observe Friday’s thrilling semi-final that he in the end misplaced to Alcaraz, as did NBA participant Bradley Beal and a contingent of other supporters.

However Tiafoe’s saga ought to on no account be mistaken as an indication that the demographic profile of the game, particularly with respect to the boys’s sport, is altering. Traditionally, “Whites solely” on the tennis courts didn’t refer solely to the apparel, as one sports writer put it.

Concerted change can happen in sport, if concerted efforts are taken to deliver it about, and never sufficient has occurred to vary the demographic profile of tennis. That’s in sharp distinction to different well-liked sports activities.

Black athletes now comprise almost three-quarters of NBA players, however in the course of the first half of the twentieth century – till 1951 – mainstream skilled basketball was an all-White game. The same could be said for skilled soccer and baseball, which fielded their first Black gamers of the trendy period in 1946 and 1947, respectively.

These workforce sports activities have a bonus, nonetheless, in terms of diversifying that particular person sports activities don’t have. Black gamers in beforehand all-White locker rooms grew to become extra preeminent at each the skilled and the collegiate ranges at a time of broader political and societal desegregation.

As soon as Black gamers started to take part in consequential numbers in workforce sports activities from which they beforehand had been excluded – they actually “modified the sport,” bringing with them a culture-driven, athletic type of play discovered in America’s city facilities.

And as soon as that type of play took maintain, skilled basketball and soccer coaches, homeowners and collegiate coaches felt compelled to recruit extra Black athletes, significantly in soccer at sure positions like operating again and vast receiver, the place African American gamers loved a culture-driven “benefit” of their athleticism and magnificence of play.

Black gamers in these sports activities had what I name “transactional leverage”: their abilities have been in such excessive demand that the price of excluding Black athletes from the locker room was eclipsed by the worth of together with them on school {and professional} groups.

You’ll be able to see this identical phenomenon most clearly at present with the younger, athletic, cell Black quarterbacks who’re altering the way in which that place is performed. NFL coaches and scouts are at all times on the seek for the following Patrick Mahomes or one other Lamar Jackson as quarterback – previously a place that was all however off-limits to African People.

Clearly, leaders {of professional} tennis have created packages to attempt to generate curiosity in communities of colour. America Tennis Affiliation constructed a network of junior programs, pioneered by Arthur Ashe within the Sixties to deliver the sport to underserved communities. These sorts of efforts are nice, so far as they go. The athletic expertise at any degree might be formative – even transformative – within the lives of younger athletes.

However such experiences – irrespective of how honest in objective and the way well-funded they is likely to be – are by no means adequate to guarantee broad entry and alternative on the highest ranges of competitors and achievement. That takes years of monetary funding and intensive tutelage from a really younger age, the sort of instruction that Tiafoe bought on his residence tennis court docket and Williams acquired from her father. The publicity to the sport that the USTA is providing younger gamers isn’t almost adequate to realize the identical outcomes.

Nor do such efforts fully counteract the long-established and deeply-rooted custom of Black exclusion within the tennis tradition, which can’t be overstated. It has impeded progressive change at each degree of the game.

There isn’t any leveraged stress on tennis sports activities associations or different gatekeeper administrative authority to make the sport extra accessible to Black gamers. And to be trustworthy about it, the game is outlined in its very essence by a type of nation membership elitism that’s antithetical to higher inclusiveness. Or as one writer for Vice put it, Tennis stays “maybe the final international occasion to stay staunchly white in its sensibilities and members.”

Desegregation of the American locker rooms within the highest profile workforce sports activities didn’t occur out of a way of morality or equity. It didn’t occur as a result of it was “the suitable factor to do.”

League officers operating mainstream sports activities – usually below political stress due to broader societal change and by lobbying by the Black press and African American leaders – more and more deemed it advantageous to permit Black gamers to routinely showcase their skills in beforehand “Whites-only” mainstream workforce sports activities.

Against this, you might have a genial particular person like Tiafoe, who for all of his spectacular on-court abilities is swimming in opposition to the tide, and nearly alone, in tennis. In some methods it was his poverty – not privilege – that offered his unconventional path to the game.

Many White tennis gamers say they grew up enjoying the game; Tiafoe literally grew up on a tennis court docket, residing for a time together with his father in a spare workplace on the tennis facility his dad helped preserve. His is a one-of-a-kind state of affairs, one which’s unlikely to be repeated.

There’s, in fact, a chicken-or-the-egg facet to the issue of Blacks in tennis. There could be extra Black champions if African People had higher entry to tennis courts, significantly in city areas, together with the suitable coaching and tools. And if the tennis world noticed that extra Black champions might emerge from such settings, maybe they might do extra to put money into bringing extra alternatives to younger gamers in these communities.

May Tiafoe present such a spark? He has said that he hopes he’ll be capable of encourage different African People to take up the game. “On the finish of the day I really like that due to Frances Tiafoe there’s lots of people of colour enjoying tennis. That’s clearly a purpose for me. That’s why I’m out right here attempting fairly onerous,” he instructed members of the press throughout his storied US Open run.

A laudable sentiment, and perhaps he’ll succeed. However all the pieces I’ve discovered from many years of finding out the Black expertise tells me that his breakthrough is not going to be sufficient to comb away many years of institutional tradition in a sport that has been traditionally cussed to vary.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:




More like this