2022 Education Department issues new guidance to prevent ‘accreditation-shopping’


This audio is auto-generated. Please tell us when you’ve got suggestions.

 The U.S. Division of Schooling launched steering Tuesday that would make it more durable for faculties to change accreditors — probably establishing a conflict with a brand new Florida legislation requiring the state’s public faculties to vary accrediting businesses each accreditation cycle. 

The guidance requires faculties to acquire the company’s approval earlier than they try to change accreditors or else threat dropping entry to federal monetary help. The Ed Division will weigh a number of components to make sure faculties aren’t trying to evade oversight by altering businesses. That features assessing whether or not an establishment is prone to being sanctioned by its present accreditor. 

Primarily, the Ed Division should be satisfied that schools are altering accreditors to enhance their high quality, Cynthia Jackson-Hammond, president of the Council for Larger Schooling Accreditation, stated in an e mail. 

“That is an extra requirement for establishments, making the method of doubtless altering accreditors very time intensive,” Jackson-Hammond stated. 

In a weblog publish asserting the steering, the Ed Division cited the Florida legislation. Lawmakers there handed the accreditation legislation earlier this yr, prompting the Ed Division to warn state officers that the coverage may endanger faculties’ access to federal financial aid

Jackson-Hammond has beforehand argued the Florida legislation will place a big burden on faculties, which should rent extra workers to satisfy the necessities of 1 accreditor whereas concurrently making use of for an additional. Students could have to select up the tab, she wrote in a March letter to Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, a Republican.  

“The affect right here — the place Florida is requiring that establishments change accreditors each 5 years — is unsure,” Jackson-Hammond stated Wednesday. 

Considerations over ‘accreditation-shopping’

Larger schooling’s accreditation system is supposed to make sure that faculties present high quality schooling, are financially wholesome and repeatedly enhance by peer evaluate. With no seal of approval from federally acknowledged accreditors, faculties can’t obtain federal monetary help. 

However accreditors have lengthy confronted criticism that they aren’t offering sufficient oversight. And issues abound that schools can swap to extra lenient accreditors to keep away from punishment for poor pupil outcomes or missing sources for schooling — a technique known as accreditation-shopping. 

The Ed Division stated its new insurance policies are supposed to stop one of these “race to the underside,” in accordance with a blog post from Antoinette Flores, a senior advisor within the company’s postsecondary schooling division. 

The Florida legislation prompted the Ed Division to launch the steering, in accordance with the publish. However the steering was additionally sparked by laws issued throughout the Trump administration that eradicated the standard geographical boundaries for regional accreditors, main some businesses to develop their territories. 

These adjustments have been “complicated to establishments and can also have a chilling impact on accrediting businesses as they search to successfully do their job,” Flores wrote. 

With a couple of exceptions, the Ed Division stated it could not be cheap for faculties to change accreditors if their accreditation had been withdrawn prior to now two years or if that they had lately been topic to probation or different punishment. 

“They should be in good standing earlier than they’re in a position to swap,” stated Kevin Kinser, a better schooling professor at Penn State College. 

Schools are ‘caught between two masters’

Beneath present laws, the Ed Division will solely acknowledge accreditors whose faculties are voluntarily selecting to be their members.

“This voluntary affiliation is meant to engender a prepared and cooperative surroundings for the evaluate and enchancment of academic applications at American establishments of upper schooling,” the Ed Division wrote in a Tuesday letter to accrediting businesses. 

Nonetheless, Florida’s legislation “probably undermines the voluntary nature of the connection,” the division argued. In response, the company is inspecting whether or not faculties are voluntarily in search of membership when they’re trying to change accreditors. The Ed Division additionally stated it could contemplate the difficulty of voluntary membership when deciding whether or not to proceed recognizing accreditors. 

Larger schooling consultants say these Ed Division insurance policies may conflict with Florida’s legislation, although the impacts to the state’s faculties are nonetheless unknown. 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:




More like this